Traditional Diets

food

Examples:  Weston A. Price Foundation, Deep Nutrition. This is how most people in the world ate between the time of the birth of agriculture (as long as 10,000 yrs ago) and the birth of industrial food processing (about 150 yrs ago). Discover what these healthy diets had in common.

STRATEGY:

Post-agricultural whole foods, emphasizing healthy animal foods and fats

FOODS:

Healthy meat, animal fats, and eggs from animals fed their ideal diets
Pastured, raw or fermented full-fat dairy products
Traditionally processed (soaked, sprouted, fermented) grains and legumes
Vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds
Discourages use of seed oils, such as canola, corn, and flax
No soy

POTENTIAL BENEFITS:

Specifically encourages whole foods and discourages modern processed foods and refined carbohydrates, therefore this diet is substantially healthier than the typical diet.

Eliminates soy, which is a potential health culprit for some people

Traditional processing of grains and legumes reduces “anti-nutrients” in these foods and improves nutrient availability.

Compared to other post-agricultural diets, this diet is much higher in omega-3 fatty acids and much lower in omega-6 fatty acids, providing a healthier omega fatty acid balance.

POTENTIAL RISKS:

This diet is nutritionally rich, therefore if you are having trouble losing weight on this diet you may need to reduce fruit/starchy vegetable intake, dairy intake, and or caloric intake in order to lose weight.

________________________________________________________________________

Who was Weston Price?

Weston Price (1870-1948) was a dentist who studied the dental health of traditional societies around the world. He found that people who were isolated from modern civilizations had strong, straight teeth free of decay and that they were far healthier in general than people who ate the modern diets of his day. He looked at what the diets of these healthy traditional peoples had in common with each other and how they were different from the modern “civilized” diets of his day so that he could understand why modern diets were less healthy. His dietary recommendations are based on his observations about these diets and are summarized at the top of this page.

His observations led him to believe that meat and fat from naturally-raised animals is healthy.

I am not aware of any modern scientific studies which have explored the potential health risks or benefits of this dietary pattern.

Dr. Price’s work is documented in his book Nutrition and Physical Degeneration.  You can learn more about his philosophy and the diet he recommended at:  www.westonaprice.org.

One modern-day physician who writes and blogs about the health benefits of traditional dietary strategies is Dr. Cate Shanahan, author of Deep Nutrition.  Her blog provides useful information and support at www.drcate.com.

 

  • user123

    I came across this article (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20679148) that says that among South Asians studied, “combined animal protein intake (animal and fish) was more likely to be associated with diabetes (p = 0.07) than was vegetable protein intake (p = 0.26)”. Was interested to know your thoughts on this — they have some references that seem to support their assertion that too much protein may be bad for someone’s overall
    metabolic profile.

  • http://diagnosisdiet.com/ Dr. Ede

    Hello, user123
    Thank you for this excellent question. I looked at the study, and found that it suffers from the same important shortcoming that the vast majority of epidemiological studies of dietary patterns do–it does not take refined carbohydrate intake into consideration. It looks at percent carbohydrate only and does not look at carbohydrate quality. So, therefore, not only is it an epidemiological study (which cannot prove cause and effect), but it also does not control for a very powerful risk factor for diabetes, namely, refined and high glycemic index carb intake.

  • Christopher

    Hi Dr Ede
    I looked under Diets for a Ketogenic Diet
    Would it be possible for you to please add a Ketogenic Diets to your website
    Also i tried to find month one of your Ketogenic diet – i see only months 2-4 are available

    It would be much appreciated
    Thanks
    Christopher

    • http://diagnosisdiet.com/ Dr. Ede

      Hi Christopher
      I apologize for the confusion about how I organized the ketogenic diet posts–I started off calling them Nutritional Ketosis Week 1, Nutritional Ketosis Week 2, etc. and then switched to calling them Ketogenic Diet month 2, month 3&4, etc. So you are right, it is very confusing. I have ketogenic diet information under my low-carbohydrate diets tab right. If you type “ketogenic” into the search box on the home page you will see a list of blog posts pertaining to ketogenic diets. I hope that helps!

Last Modified: Oct 11, 2012 at 9:16pm